Rosie pauses to give the idea some genuine thought, the kind it deserves. There is something oddly intimate about Caleb knowing her in a way that not even Nick or Sabrina could manage even with all their magic, and it's fascinating and a little frightening all at once. She could say no, and Caleb would respect it; even without any abilities to speak of, Rosie knows that without question. It makes answering him easy.

"You can ask me," she says. "As long as it's okay if I don't always want to tell you why."